Not earning income but CSA still wants money
November 19, 2012
I lost my job in june 2011 but carried on paying my CSA support as in my view not the kids fault. I did not sign on as the plan was to start up a business with an associate but it would be a year before we could draw any income, formed the company in approx January 2012. I informed the CSA.
I stopped paying the CSA in January as i had run out of funds. Despite having no income the CSA continue to back date my money at the full rate. I resigned from the company in june 2012 because my new wife was moving abroad and they still continue to build up my back pay.
How is this fair when I have not been earning an income ?
Related
Written by neal handforth · Filed Under CSA Advice
Related CSA Posts
Comments
10 Responses to “Not earning income but CSA still wants money”
Got something to say?

Tell us your CSA story
Do you want to be heard?
Tell us your story of how the CSA has treated you. We might be able to help, and could publish your tale on the website to make sure everyone knows about the problems you've had.
Forum Login
Child Support Agency Poll
Loading ...
CSAhell.com on Facebook
Search CSAhell.com
Child Support Agency (CSA) Advice
CSAhell.com has been set up to help you with your child support agency problems. If you're having difficulty getting the CSA to listen you can tell your story here. Get advice on dealing with the CSA at CSAhell.com.Subscribe
Enter your email address to receive child support agency advice and news direct to your inbox.
Recent Forum Replies
-
Doogle on csa arrears after case closed confused?
7 months, 1 week ago -
angela456 on Small CSA Victory
1 year, 4 months ago -
darwinmiller on Brand new forum
2 years, 4 months ago -
Michael – CSAhell.com staff on LTD COMPANY QUESTION
2 years, 9 months ago -
metalman750 on LTD COMPANY QUESTION
2 years, 12 months ago
-
Recent Forum Topics
-
csa arrears after case closed confused?
by
jimgsd
7 months, 1 week ago -
Pay Your Way – Avoid The CSA
by
arealman
1 year, 1 month ago -
Can the CSA find me?
by
amc123
1 year, 3 months ago -
CSA to CMS
by
markburtonmark
1 year, 7 months ago -
Small CSA Victory
by
markburtonmark
1 year, 4 months ago
-
csa arrears after case closed confused?
by
-
Recent Posts
- Contradictory CMS needs to be abolished
- Dated CSA not fit for purpose by leaving fathers willing to pay with nothing
- What gives the CMS the right to give out false information?
- My advice to combat the CSA after a 20 year battle
- All I want is financial support for my daughter
- CMS are putting a huge strain on my family
- I want to pay for my child, but CSA makes it hard to get by
- CSA treat dads like criminals regardless of circumstances
- CMS upped payments and won’t offer any kind of solution
- Ex stole child away from me and now wants to bleed me dry
- Fathers who try to evade CSA by emigrating should have passports taken off them!
- CSA hounding me for arrears even though I had no income at all!
- Can my husband claim back historical CSA payments back due to age?
- I won’t pay CSA if I can’t be a dad to my son
- The system is not fair to my boyfriend who has 50/50 custody
Categories
- Child Support Agency (111)
- CSA Advice (2,225)
- CSA Complaints (3,080)
- CSA Help (1,015)
- CSA Mistakes (392)
- CSA News (148)
- Events & Protests (8)
- General (1)
- Guest Posts (1)
- Website Updates (9)
CSA Comments
- David on Dated CSA not fit for purpose by leaving fathers willing to pay with nothing
- Billy the Kid on My advice to combat the CSA after a 20 year battle
- Peter Andersom on My advice to combat the CSA after a 20 year battle
- David on All I want is financial support for my daughter
- Peter on CSA hounding me for arrears even though I had no income at all!
- David on I want to pay for my child, but CSA makes it hard to get by
- geoff banks on I won’t pay CSA if I can’t be a dad to my son
- geoff banks on Can I get any of my ex’s injury compensation?
CSA Websites
-
Popular CSA posts today
- CSA Calculator 84 views | 0 comments
- CSA Calculated Payment 78 views | 0 comments
- How to beat the CSA 47 views | 0 comments
- I am not on birth cirtifi... 31 views | 0 comments
- Will the CSA take my new... 22 views | 0 comments
- Contradictory CMS needs t... 20 views | 0 comments
- How do you avoid paying t... 15 views | 0 comments
- Deduction from Earnings O... 12 views | 0 comments
- What percentage of my sal... 12 views | 0 comments
- What if I can’t afford to... 10 views | 0 comments
Archives
- April 2018 (8)
- March 2018 (6)
- February 2018 (32)
- January 2018 (4)
- December 2017 (9)
- November 2017 (20)
- October 2017 (15)
- September 2017 (14)
- August 2017 (8)
- July 2017 (10)
- June 2017 (19)
- May 2017 (20)
- April 2017 (16)
- March 2017 (19)
- February 2017 (14)
- January 2017 (15)
- December 2016 (15)
- November 2016 (35)
- October 2016 (26)
- September 2016 (13)
- August 2016 (23)
- July 2016 (22)
- June 2016 (16)
- May 2016 (21)
- April 2016 (20)
- March 2016 (27)
- February 2016 (29)
- January 2016 (23)
- December 2015 (25)
- November 2015 (30)
- October 2015 (31)
- September 2015 (29)
- August 2015 (30)
- July 2015 (70)
- June 2015 (91)
- May 2015 (93)
- April 2015 (90)
- March 2015 (93)
- February 2015 (84)
- January 2015 (83)
- December 2014 (77)
- November 2014 (86)
- October 2014 (94)
- September 2014 (89)
- August 2014 (94)
- July 2014 (93)
- June 2014 (91)
- May 2014 (93)
- April 2014 (82)
- March 2014 (83)
- February 2014 (83)
- January 2014 (97)
- December 2013 (100)
- November 2013 (122)
- October 2013 (124)
- September 2013 (120)
- August 2013 (126)
- July 2013 (124)
- June 2013 (122)
- May 2013 (124)
- April 2013 (120)
- March 2013 (118)
- February 2013 (63)
- January 2013 (96)
- December 2012 (93)
- November 2012 (92)
- October 2012 (95)
- September 2012 (92)
- August 2012 (93)
- July 2012 (93)
- June 2012 (103)
- May 2012 (93)
- April 2012 (66)
- March 2012 (65)
- February 2012 (64)
- January 2012 (73)
- December 2011 (75)
- November 2011 (75)
- October 2011 (99)
- September 2011 (60)
- August 2011 (63)
- July 2011 (68)
- June 2011 (61)
- May 2011 (75)
- April 2011 (66)
- March 2011 (68)
- February 2011 (62)
- January 2011 (68)
- December 2010 (64)
- November 2010 (60)
- October 2010 (62)
- September 2010 (61)
- August 2010 (66)
- July 2010 (65)
- June 2010 (61)
- May 2010 (65)
- April 2010 (60)
- March 2010 (64)
- February 2010 (46)
- January 2010 (23)
- December 2009 (26)
- November 2009 (44)
- October 2009 (4)
- September 2009 (8)
- August 2009 (3)
- July 2009 (15)
- June 2009 (30)
- May 2009 (14)
- April 2009 (2)
- March 2009 (2)
- February 2009 (5)
- January 2009 (5)
- December 2008 (2)
- November 2008 (3)
- October 2008 (3)
- September 2008 (7)
- August 2008 (1)
- July 2008 (8)
- June 2008 (23)
- May 2008 (20)
- April 2008 (28)
- March 2008 (11)
The CSA have the right to keep an assessment in place. If you had claimed JSA then they would have reduced your assessment.
if you had advised the agency when you stopped working and stated that you were not going to claim benefit then a nil assessment would have been put in place. If you do not advise of a change of circumstances then your last assessment will remain in place.
it is your responsibility to report any change of circumstances to the CSA within 7 days
neal,
Can you confirm – are you disputing the CSA you paid between June 11 – Jan 12 OR the amount that has allegedly become due after you (quote neal) ‘ …formed the company in approx January 2012. I informed the CSA.’ ?
What exactly did you inform the CSA?
How did you contact the CSA, in writing or by phone?
chall ~ afairercsaforall
Hi I informed them in writing I would not be claiming benefit and that would keep paying my payments as long as possible. I then informed them in writing in January I could no longer make the payments and also informed them that I had started my own business. So in summary it was my decsion to keep supporting my children. Its the from January I am disputing ?
Also I believe its my duty as the father to provide support for my children and will continue to do so past the age of 19. But when I have never missed a payment in 12 years I would expect they could see this and have a sensible conversation to help me as well as my boys.
as you informed them when you lost your job and advised that you would not be claiming benefit but intended to continue with your payments this would be taken as you requesting that they did not re-assess your case with a nil assessment based on nil income – as such the last maintenance calculation would be left in place and your account would continue to charge weekly by that amount.
When you then contacted them to state that your circumstances had changed with you starting a new business your case would be re-assessed as an NRP notified change and a new assessment would be needed in respect of your new income. Did you have any income from the business? If so were you self-employed (as in submitting a Self-assessment tax return) or were you paid as a Director under PAYE? If you had any income from the business you will be liable.
When you resigned in June 2012 did you inform the CSA at that point? How did you support yourself financially since you resigned?
Respect to yourself that you continued to pay in the period that you had no income and would have been entitled to a nil assessment.
I informed the csa that had no drawings as a company director and they only asked me to prove I had resigned which I did. I asked them what the correct procedure was and followed this to the tee. I was never given the option to be re assed at that stage. My wife supported us for this period which obviously has been difficult but we have managed so far. It makes you appreciate a lot of things. I hoping I can find a job soon as there is not a day goes by I dont think about my boys.
I informed the csa that had no drawings or earnings and as a company director, they only asked me to prove I had resigned which I did. I asked them what the correct procedure was and followed this to the tee. I was never given the option to be re assed at that stage. My wife supported us for this period which obviously has been difficult but we have managed so far. It makes you appreciate a lot of things. I hoping I can find a job soon as there is not a day goes by I dont think about my boys.
if you have informed the csa that you are now not working and not claiming benefit then you should currently be entitled to a nil assessment now.
When you contacted the agency in January to inform them you were starting work with the new company did they ask what you were earning? The agency need to have wage information provided either by the NRP or the NRP employer in order to calculate an assessment.
Have you received a maintenance calculation letter from them since January? If so what does it say the assessment is based on and what was the weekly maintenance stated? If you have not received a letter you need to contact them and ask what the current maintenance calculation is and when it is effective from.
If you had told them in Jan you were going to be starting work but not actually earning anything then a nil assessment should have been processed … if this has not happened and your last maintenance calc is still in place then it will continue to charge weekly and this is where the arrears will be accrued from. If this is the case then once a nil assessment is put in place back to January the arrears will self-adjust and you will owe nothing.
Another possibility is a DMD (Default Maintenance Decision) – this would be put in place if the NRP or NRP employer fails to provide wages information. Clearly you have said you told them you would be working but not earning, but if this was missed by the case worker when checking the file and they sent our a wages enquiry form to the company and did not receive this back then they would put a DMD in place 9£30 for 1 child, £40 for 2 children and £50 for 3 or more children) Again if this was done you would have been issued with a Maintenance Calculation notification. If this is what has happened and you now provide the income details – in your case nil (they might confirm this with the company) then the DMD can be converted and a nil assessment would be put in place, this would be effective back to the same date as the DMD.
It might also be helpful for you to request a client statement which will show you all charges made on the account and all payments received, this way you will be able to see where the arrears have accrued from.
Good luck and come back with any further info you get
You don’t stop being obligated to support your kids just because you’re a failure. Get a job washing dishes or cleaning up rubbish. Be a man.